Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Search isn't that business since staying small means you won't be able to create a good index of the world. And you won't have enough resources for your browser.


Except Kagi often delivers better results than the modern, Ad, SEO and AI generated stuff that google delivers nowadays. And the most important selling point: You can block certain domains which vastly improves the results.


For me it is a great index, much better than all the alternatives. Especially against Google that is now filled with AI and Ads. Sometimes so bad, you really have to scroll down, to get to the first non-Ad link.


Google has a powerful commercial incentive to deliver mediocre search performance.

If search works well, the result you wanted is in the first spot on page #1. This is a bad outcome for Google.

The more follow up searches you run and the more trash you wade through, the more ads you see and the more money Google makes.


But it's not their index. Without Google or bing, they fall.


Kagi has its own index

https://help.kagi.com/kagi/search-details/search-sources.htm...

It also uses other indices along Google.


I love how transparent they are about everything, and even that they show stats on "most blocked domain".

Unsurprisingly it's Pintrest that annoys people the most.


> unsurprisingly

I haven't used Kagi much, but I don't think I've ever seen a single Pinterest result from any other search engine, I barely even know what the thing is for.

Is this a US thing? A Kagi quirk specifically?


Maybe you just don't really search for images? Pinterest constantly comes up in image search results and then doesn't actually let you view or download the full image until you sign up.


It also removes sources, so that awesome looking bag only comes up as Pintrest pins and not anywhere that actually sells it.


I am not US based.

And to be honest, I don't see as much Pintrest crap as I used to. It may just be that it has fallen out of favour because of its terrible design. But it was a site that basically let you create mood boards from images that you found as your browsed.

The big problem with it was that it simply copied the image so if you were looking for anything, Pintrest came up with the images for a product but then had removed all the source so it just flooded search results with uncited references and you couldn't find anything useful.

Reverse image searching to find sites thst sold a prpduct became useless.


Possibly a US thing, definitely not a Kagi thing. Useless Pintrest results (especially in image search) that don't actually the thing they pretend to are ubiquitous on Google.


It has. But in my experience their own index is rarely used

> All results from external indexes.

The above is something I see all the time when using Kagi.


I've never seen that, do I need to turn on a setting to show the indices used or something?


It is shown under the search box right before the first result


Ah so it is (on desktop site), thanks. 'test' -> '58% unique Kagi results'; 'test2' -> 'all results from external indexes'.


Why? I think that's an extraordinary claim.


Because it's expensive, and kagi still doesn't have one? And the browser is very incomplete? This is all pretty basic, how many global Web indices do you think exist?


I agree for the index, much less for the browser. I'm using Orion since a few months and beside some occasiona bugs I wouldn't ask anything more. If it was open source it would be perfect.

On the index side I agree, I think they are using other people indexes so far, I don't know if they are thinking about building one themselves.

Same for LLM, but I think that there the problem is even worse.


>how many global Web indices do you think exist?

Here's a list for the curious:

>A look at search engines with their own indexes

https://seirdy.one/posts/2021/03/10/search-engines-with-own-...


And yet, somehow, they've managed quite well :^)


They haven't, but also that wasn't the argument


Huh? Kagi is objectively superior to Google/Bing at this point, to the point that 50k people are willingly paying $10/mo extra for it.

Obviously they don't have the ancillary services (Maps etc), but for just searching, Kagi is far more likely to surface useful results instead of just the highest bidder. Compare a search like "us esta" for a clear demonstration.


>Kagi is objectively superior to Google/Bing at this point

I'm not entirely sure what "objectively superior" is even supposed to mean in the context of a search engine, or how this follows from having 50k users, but that ceases to be an even remotely plausible statement if you've ever attempted to get good non-English search results.


Kagi gives great search results in other languages than English. You might have to select the right region first. Kagi and Google are the only search engines I have tried that gives decent results for other languages than English.


Huh indeed, you're talking about yet another argument, but just as wrong as the previous pivot:

First search result for "us esta" in Google is "https://esta.cbp.dhs.gov/esta", same as in kagi, is that your objectivite fail at coming up with a simple metric?


Are you using an ad blocker or something? For me it's the 11th (!) link on mobile, far below the fold.


Can confirm, official page is first result in Kagi and below the fold in Google for me.


For me on desktop it was 3 giant ads but then the first real link was that one.


Any adverts and the competition is over as far as I’m concerned. I happily pay not to see them.


uBlock Origin is free.


Sure an ad blocker improves the experience somewhat. But I try to keep adversarial relationships out of my life. I don't understand why people want to normalize this.


Only in Firefox or user-friendly browsers, otherwise uBlock Lite is free for Manifest v3 browsers


Both block all Google search ads fully and seamlessly.


but they don't block sponsored/seo-gamed articles, no?


Neither does Kagi, at least fully. Customizations help a bit until you need to search for something outside your usual focus areas. Anyone who claims to have created a search engine that truly surfaces the best links and ignores SEO is lying to you.


That covers half of it, and indeed I do also rely on community and personal block/deranking lists for SEO spam.

Does ublock or ddg etc block sponsored results?


iOS Firefox doesn't support extensions nor does it have proper adblocking.


I don't want to scroll around and decide what is real on every search.


Thanks - I'll try and remember that!


Might be location-dependent. I'm on a trip in Turkey, and the corretct link to US ESTA is the first result. However, if I switch to a VPN to my home, I get garbage for the first 5 results.

I also have my own WTFs with Google, I even started collecting them: https://imgur.com/a/bgFax59


First search result in Google for me is "https://esta.visasyst.com/", second one is "https://evisa.us/application/esta", third one is "https://www.usimmigrationsupport.org/esta".

First one on Kagi is the official US government ESTA website.


What is "objectivite"?


The mineral form of objective; mainly mined in the Rockies but the EU and Australia have large untapped deposits of it.


Oh I see, thank you. Does it react to subjectivite?


Kagi is a meta-search engine, they don't have their own index for the whole Internet (they do for a small subset of it).


Yes, they pay per search when using others, so I guess the best strategy is to court devs, then index tech sites on your own.

Let others handle rarer queries.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: