Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Weak argument.

The objective level of reproduction of labor force is about $2 per day. Cheaper for warm climates, slightly more expensive for cold ones.

So by that logic there is no working class in the US whatsoever because you don't have to work to survive. At all. Maybe half a year in your entire lifetime.

You just choose to spend all your money on things you don't need to survive, that's the only reason you needed to work. But that doesn't make you a worker class any more than Elon Musk becomes a worker class by buying 10 companies like Twitter.

So, using your logic, "You are making more than 50 cents an hour? You're not working class. You don't have to work most of your life to survive yourself or to provide for your children. You're closer to Elon Musk than to workers forced to work for $2 a day to survive."



> The objective level of reproduction of labor force is about $2 per day. Cheaper for warm climates, slightly more expensive for cold ones.

I also like making random numbers up. Here are other numbers. 420. 1337. 1911.

> So by that logic there is no working class in the US whatsoever because you don't have to work to survive. At all. Maybe half a year in your entire lifetime.

I have no words to express how weak this argument is. The US has MOSTLY working class people because less and less people can survive on their salaries.

https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cost-of-living-income-quality-o...

> So, using your logic, "You are making more than 50 cents an hour? You're not working class. You don't have to work most of your life to survive yourself or to provide for your children. You're closer to Elon Musk than to workers forced to work for $2 a day to survive."

I am not sure if this sentence is a troll, or comes from genuine misunderstanding. I don't know what to advice. I genuinely chuckled. Here are a three numbers, elementary math:

7.25

53

1 600 000

Which two of these numbers are closer to one another? 7.25 and 53, right (I hope)? Well, let's look what those numbers mean:

7.25 - minimum wage https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/wages/minimumwage

53 - average hourly salary of a software engineer: https://www.indeed.com/career/software-engineer/salaries

1 600 000 average hourly wage of Elon Musk: https://moneyzine.com/personal-finance/how-much-does-elon-mu...

So...who is a software engineer closer in terms of income to? Elon Musk or a minimum wage worker?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: