Makes me think of that chapter in Infinite Jest where videoconferencing gets popular, until people start using "optimized" computer-rendered images instead of showing their actual faces, at which point everyone goes back to audio-only.
I wouldn't mind video conferencing with computer generated avatars. I don't video conference to know what the other person looks like, and in fact knowing what they look like just creates lots of unnecessary bias. I do it for the cues from their gestures, facial expressions, the direction they are looking, etc. With a good tracking setup that works perfectly well today with digital avatars.
Anyway, your comment is bullshit. I'm a white guy (actually from Spain, so I don't know if I qualify as "white" from the USA point of view) living in Japan, so I am the discriminated minority here (and yes, I have been a victim of minor racism), and I agree with GP. We humans evolved for face to face conversation, if racism is the problem, hiding behind a mask is not the solution.
Because racism exists and is a real problem for lots of people.
You don't fix that by pretending race doesn't matter, because in the lived experience of all of those people, it matters, a lot. They would love it if it didn't matter, but that is not what happens in reality.
It doesn't prevent discrimination, it just allows me to do what I want to do in the short term, e.g. raise funding for startups or get dream jobs or whatever.
I mean if a VC hands me a term sheet or a hiring manager hands me a job and the ONLY thing I misrepresented is my face, I don't think they have any ethical grounds to retract their offer.
Solving the discrimination problem is another matter, and will take years if not decades, my dreams cannot wait for that.
Sincerely, I'm sorry you feel that you haven't achieved certain things because of skin colour/accent/etc. However let me challenge that belief, only because if your assumption isn't true, that your lack of desired success is because of things outside of your control, then perhaps you won't make the adjustments potentially needed to actually achieve them. If your dreams truly cannot wait (as you said, and they shouldn't!), then imaginary AI solutions to not-catastrophic-not-life-ending barriers shouldn't be seen as anything relevant to your eventual success.
None of us can control skin colour, accent, connected families, or other benefits that others may have. But we can outwork the privileged, and today's world, with just a computer and internet connectivity, gives us all much more options than previously imaginable.
I do sincerely wish you great luck and success, but I really think you shouldn't get stuck on things you can't control, and devote all your energy to things you can.
Oh yes of course. I just think it would be a super cool technical project to actually make this work real time in a videoconference, and there would be lots of use cases for it. Eliminating survey biases during interview-style surveys is another.
Good luck to you. I am not convinced people would be more likely to give money or a job to someone when they have only seen an avatar, but what do I know.
If you deceive someone by wearing a different face during an interview, I expect that you would not be hired. How do you prove you were the person interviewed?
There are plenty of ways to prove that, including stating a public key during the interview, interviewer signs it with their key, vice versa is done with the interviewer's key, and then the same is demonstrated in person with the same keys.
Hell, how to do that can even be an interview question.
That's a terrible answer to the hypothetical interview question because your solution only works if the person that took the interview is not colluding with the person that wants the job. The interviewee could just email their private key to the job seeker.
The key signing only protects against some very uncommon threats
That defeats the entire purpose of using facial and body expressions that only video provides.
We already have video filters that remove wrinkles and blemishes in videoconferencing to make you look better.
Even if we replace ourselves entirely with computer-rendered images, they're still going to be reproducing our expressions, movements and gestures, which is what matters.
My phone already has a video call beautification setting built into the OS at the camera level.
We've been skirting the line for a while.
If I could, right now I absolutely would prefer to be sending a synthesized avatar then the real me - my desktop setup doesn't allow very optimal camera placement with large monitors, but for maximum impact I ideally want to send my face making direct eye contact with the camera.
Is there a filter available that just fixes the apparent direction of the pupil, so the image is looking at the camera, without doing any other edits? That would be really useful.
Makes me think of that chapter in Infinite Jest where videoconferencing gets popular, until people start using "optimized" computer-rendered images instead of showing their actual faces, at which point everyone goes back to audio-only.